If the OP does the roll-over as per above, there will be no "after-tax" in the IRA to create a proration concern.Are you retired or have another 401k to roll the rollover IRA into? Cuz one thing that hasn't been mentioned yet in this thread is sending your stuff to a rollover IRA will require you to do pro-rata calculations in the future if you do backdoor Roth IRA conversions. To save this potential headache, you could opt to keep the pre-tax 401k balance and the cap gains balance in the existing 401k plan.I've called again today and got someone more clueful on the phone. Here's the result:
* Pre-tax 401k balance -----------------------> Rollover IRA
* Roth 401k balance --------------------------> Roth IRA
* After-tax elective/voluntary balance ----> Roth IRA
* Cap gains balance ---------------------------> Rollover IRA
This is exactly what I wanted. Should be zero tax liability as the gains were pushed into pre-tax IRA space.
When I retired, I had some "after-tax" in my 401K which Fidelity rolled into a Roth, and the "pre-tax" went into a Roll-Over IRA. Final result -- the IRA was 100% pre-tax, no pro-rata. I did not have any 401K Roth $ as only became available the year I retired.
Statistics: Posted by RetiredAL — Mon Mar 04, 2024 9:15 pm